Tuesday, April 3, 2018

Mindlab Week 17 Reflective Practice

My current Reflective Practice


To be totally honest, my current reflective practice is like this image - done but not clear to see the reflection - you can see that it is a reflection but you can't see what is being reflected.

In other words, it is mostly done in my head and researched but not documented in any sort of reflective journaling. I respond to the needs of my students, discuss things with my colleagues, research ideas and support, and then adapt and add things to my classroom programme as I need. I struggle to find time to document this reflective process, I view my main need / focus to be in the classroom. I need to find the purpose for writing it down / documenting it in some way - who is it for, what will it do in the future, why do I need to do it?

I have always liked the idea of documenting my reflection in some way and have greatly admired the teaching blogs of colleagues. I have learnt a great amount from them and the teachers in the Twitter education community. On occasion, I have attempted to document my thoughts on this blog. I consider myself to be a reflective teacher and can identify with the ideas of Schon's reflection-on-action and reflection-in-action (Finlay 2008), I just don't have any documented evidence other than the actions I put into place, the changes made in the classroom.
The biggest mental hurdle for me has been seeing the purpose - few blogs get comments from others on them - they get read but the engagement and conversation never really gets off the ground. My question for myself is do I need those comments / interactions? Is this a place for me to get my thoughts out of my head? Does it matter if other people don't interact with them?
As Finlay (2008) says "It also tends to involve the individual practitioner in
being self-aware and critically evaluating their own responses to practice situations.
The point is to recapture practice experiences and mull them over critically in order to
gain new understandings and so improve future practice. This is understood as part of the
process of life-long learning."

My aim is to now look at how I reflect and how I document that reflection - Zeichner and Liston's  (1996) reflective levels particularly resonated with me - I feel like I already do numbers 1, 2, and 4 (to some extent) but that I need to work on number 3 and 5.

1. Rapid reflection - immediate, ongoing and automatic action by the teacher.
2. Repair – in which a thoughtful teacher makes decisions to alter their behaviour in
response to students’ cues.
3. Review – when a teacher thinks about, discusses or writes about some element of their
teaching.
4. Research – when a teacher engages in more systematic and sustained thinking over
time, perhaps by collecting data or reading research.
5. Retheorizing and reformulating – the process by which a teacher critically examines
their own practice and theories in the light of academic theories.

This blog will be my opportunity to do that - to be my own commenter / to feedback to myself and have that conversation to improve my practise. My first step will be to schedule in a regular time to do this.

My I

Tuesday, January 2, 2018

Reflection thoughts on Grant Lichtman Ted Talk: 


20th vs 21st Century
We are now a knowledge creating society / education system rather than just a knowledge consuming system - teachers and students become creators AND consumers of knowledge

In his book, #Edjourney - A roadmap to the future of education, Lichtman lists a set of skills that students need to survive in the future: persistence, confidence, resilience, patience, openness, creativity, adaptability, courage, perspective, empathy, and self-control.

It seems to me that the skills from the 20th century are now the beginning of learning, the front loading for our students - the research, the knowledge gathering, consuming aspects of learning; then the 21st century skills come to the front and we take that knowledge further - create, innovate, fail, build on the knowledge of the past. 21st C skills are building on the foundations that 20th century skills have made - now it's about what you do with the foundations


A few blogs I have found on the subject that echo aspects of my thoughts:




In the book Key Competencies for the Future, by Rosemary Hipkins, Rachel Bolstad, Sally Boyd, Sue McDowall, the authors pose several scenarios that ask us to think about how we would implement our NZ curriculum in innovative, future focussed ways.

My notes from Grant Lichtman "What 60 Schools Can Tell Us About Teaching 21st Century Skill" video

The following are my jottings from viewing Grant Lichtman's Ted Talk: "What 60 Schools Can Tell Us About Teaching 21st Century Skill" - things that stuck with me.

Critical thinking / problem solving
Asking questions more than giving answers
Systems rather than compartmentalising into subject silos
Finding problems rather than solving problems

Change in education is complicated, messy but is it hard?

Schools are permeable - off campus / online

No switching between brains - maths / science - crossing barriers of subjects

Self-correcting

Authentic reflection - thinking about what we are doing, empathy

Creative spaces

Thinking, designing building

We are a knowledge based industry

Who controls education? The adults or the learners?

Content rather than context - how can we flip that around?

Teach into the unknown - we don't know what the future is, we don't know what the skills are - need to teach our students to be self-evolving learners which means our schools need to become self-evolving instituatuions

Prepare students for their future not their own past

“If we teach today’s students as we taught yesterday’s, we rob them of tomorrow.”

― John Dewey

“Our job as teachers and parents is not to prepare students for something; our job is to help students prepare themselves for anything.” AJ Juliani

Saturday, December 2, 2017

Mind Lab Session 2 notes

Notes from session 2 of Mind Lab

 "Learners are most likely to develop and strengthen their capabilities for living and learning when they learn with teachers in a school whose leadership creates conditions that stimulate key competencies." (MoE, 2014). 

KC's need to be a living breathing part of school life and culture - not only the students following them, but the leaders of the school - all parties involved. Do our communities follow them as well?

Knowledge as a verb - a living breathing thing, we play an active role in creating knowledge

School values shouldn't need to be displayed - people should be able to arrive at the school and be able to tell you what your values are - you are living the values rather than just saying what they are

Shared google doc about knowledge as a verb


If we want to be responsible educators what we do in the classroom it has to be research informed and it definitely needs to be evidence based. What we say about our students needs to be evidence based.

Thought leadership - explaining what you are doing, justifying why you are doing that.

KCs are the keys to what? What leadership doors do they open?

Thinking - openness to new ways of doing things, analysis, how can we do things better, vision - where are we going? What is the purpose - lead a group to come up with the collective vision.

Using lang: leaders need to be skilled communicators


KCs and He Tikanga Whakaaro
He Tikanga Whakaaro suggests a Maori way of thinking / understanding. Macfarlane et al (2008) provide the following comparison between the KCs and the concepts of He Tikanga Whakaaro.
Key CompetenciesHe Tikanga Whakaaro
Thinking
Using language, symbols & texts
Tātaritanga (thinking and making meaning)
Managing selfRangatiratanga (personal autonomy and leadership)
Whakawhanaungatanga (establishing relationships)
Relating to othersManaakitanga (a context of caring relationships)
Participating and contributingWhaiwahitanga (engagement and participation).

Leadership is part and parcel of what is expected of teachers

Reflective thinking turns experience into insights


Sunday, November 19, 2017

Resurrecting!

Dragging this blog out of the attic and starting it again!

The cobwebs have been blown off because now I'm taking part in the Mind Lab Postgraduate Certificate in Applied Practice - Digital and Collaborative Learning.

We had our first session on Thursday and the main thinking from this week was What is Knowledge and What is the purpose of education?

For me the purpose of education is shifting - we are moving from education being the sharing of collective knowledge to it being about what do you do with the knowledge. Knowledge learning is still an important part but now the emphasis is moving to how can we use that, how can we take it further, what can we do with the knowledge that is different than what we do now?

The purpose of education is to create functional members of society and currently what that is, is changing. Our society is changing rapidly and our roles within society are changing, so how do we educate our students to cope with that? The skill set we leave them with are the tools of their future.

“Our job as teachers and parents is not to prepare students for something; our job is to help students prepare themselves for anything.”  AJ Juliani 

Friday, October 2, 2015

When should we be flexible with what science tells us? Science vs. Experience

I had an interesting conversation with the DoC ranger I was working with yesterday, while we were checking a trapping line. He doesn't come from a science background but has been doing this job or similar for many years and has a wealth of experience in the field of trapping and predator management.

I was busy asking a variety of questions to try and work out the science behind the trapping regime and work out the NOS in all of this - the application of science is clear to see.

What struck me was that science has determined where the traps should be set and how far they should be spaced for the supposed maximum effect. It has also determined which traps and baits to use, yet there were obvious improvements that could be made in the placements of the traps.

What is our goal here? Were we trapping to gather data or were we trapping to eradicate the predators and give the skinks the best possible chance.

This is where it all becomes a grey area. Science gives us the best possible layout and spacing for the traps via numerous studies and previous trapping success but on ground experience shows that there are better places to locate the traps - e.g. nearer shaded rocks vs. exposed in the middle of a tussock area.

My DoC ranger friend was frustrated that management and higher up didn't want to listen to his experience - to move a trap closer to rocks etc. He was also frustrated that they collected so much data on the predator caught in each trap, bait used and trap type and yet it didn't seem that that information wasn't being analysed to improve the trapping programme in the area.


The questions this brought to mind with science in general are: How flexible should management / scientists be in their setting of policies using the science learned? What about the fact that each site is different and does the science transfer across locations?
Are the purposes for using the science clear? Is it just to gather data or is it to have the best possible outcome?


Thursday, February 12, 2015

Leadership

One aspect of the Science Teaching Leadership Programme is Leadership (strangely enough!).

Leadership has never been one of my focuses. In fact it has usually been something that I have always said I will never do! That was, I guess, because of my definition of leadership and my experiences. My father has always been my teaching role model and he has always rejected leadership opportunities / offers - 30+ years of teaching and he always remained a classroom teacher, turning down HOD numerous times.

But the past few weeks of reading "The Leadership Challenge" by James Kouzes and Barry Posner(one of our required programme texts) has made me re-define what leadership is and acknowledge the fact that possibly I have already been demonstrating leadership qualities. And I know that my father was definitely a leader despite his vehement denial of it!

A leader doesn't have to have a title or be that head of department, lead teacher etc. A leader is someone who acts like a leader - out of the box thinking, willing to try new things, supporting colleagues, helping others to lead and share. I'm still working on the definition.

The point to this ramble is that I'm not feeling so apprehensive about going back to school in July and being thrust into the leadership role in science (well I am a bit still - it is a school of 600 students!). I'm starting to feel excited about all the opportunities for my school, excited to share my learning and vision, especially excited to see my thinking around science in primary schools is backed up by what I am reading and learning.

This programme is giving me the confidence and skills to be able to share my vision and stand up for what I believe is the best way for our school to create those scientifically literate citizens, those critical thinkers.

I'll blog my thoughts on the book over the next few days / blogposts.